New Five9 Study Finds 75% of Consumers Prefer Talking to a Human for Customer Service

Findings show a need to build trust and improve customer experiences to increase loyalty

New Five9 Study Finds 75% of Consumers Prefer Talking to a Human for Customer Service

Hannah Blackington
Corporate Communications Director, Five9
Press@five9.com

Five9 (NASDAQ: FIVN), provider of the Intelligent CX Platform, today released the results of a consumer survey, aimed at helping organizations understand how consumers perceive AI and evolving customer experiences. The survey explores consumer sentiments around AI and CX, as well as around holiday shopping, travel, and healthcare.

New Five9 data highlights the continued importance of the human touch in CX, as 75% prefer talking to a real human in-person or over the phone for customer support, indicating that brands need to improve online customer support. As upcoming events like open enrollment and holiday shopping create higher demand, brands will face mounting pressure to deliver exceptional CX while balancing the use of AI to enhance and streamline experiences. Given that 40% of consumers note that positive CX ensures their brand loyalty, companies must prioritize total transparency for how AI and human counterparts work together to improve customer satisfaction during peak periods.

“AI has the power to mitigate customer service frustrations, but it’s the human touch that makes the difference. By using AI to automate transactional and routine tasks, human agents can free up time to focus on more complex issues that require critical thinking and sensitivity,” said Niki Hall, Chief Marketing Officer, Five9. “As consumer demand and expectations increase this season, brands must prioritize transparency and empathy to build enduring trust and loyalty with consumers.”

The survey’s key findings include:

Consumer trust in AI is still experiencing growing pains

In the age of AI, consumers already expect some automation to be ingrained in most customer service interactions. Despite this, there is still a preference and a need for human empathy to be present alongside AI in CX. There was consensus across all generations – no matter the brand or reason for contact – that human interaction is still preferred.

84% of consumers are aware that some companies use AI to handle customer service interactions
Yet nearly half (48%) of consumers say they do not trust information provided by AI-powered customer service bots. Over half (56%) of all consumers are often frustrated by AI customer-service chatbots.

Younger generations have a better understanding of AI’s capabilities and nuances

Gen Z and Millennials find more value in AI-driven interactions compared to older generations, including chatbots and Intelligent Virtual Agents (IVAs). The use of automated solutions in CX has also led younger consumers to feel that online self-service has improved.

53% of consumers agree online self-service has improved in the last 3 years. This is higher among younger generations, including Gen Z (61%) and Millennials (61%)
Gen Z is less likely to prefer talking to a real human in-person or over the phone for customer support (66%) compared to Gen X (76%) and Baby Boomers / the Silent Generation (86%)
However, 63% of Gen Zers and 60% of Millennials say they trust information provided by AI-powered customer service bots, with 33% of both groups more likely to say they find AI very helpful and efficient

Holidays and heightened customer queries go hand-in-hand, increasing AI needs

The increase in customer queries during the holidays strongly impacts healthcare, retail, and travel organizations. 72% of older generation respondents correlated poor loyalty with poor CX.

48% of consumers say fast shipping / delivery times are most important to them when interacting with companies to do their holiday shopping, followed closely by product availability (47%)
Consumers across generations care most about appointment availability (49%) when interacting with companies while seeking healthcare services
When traveling during the holidays, consumers care most about flight or hotel availability (34%) and helpful customer experience with the business (32%)

View the complete survey results here.

To learn more about how Five9 can help improve patient loyalty and optimize the customer experience for organizations, please visit: https://www.five9.com/products-solutions

Methodology

This research was conducted in partnership with TEAM LEWIS, who surveyed 4,000 general consumers across the US and UK. All respondents were 18 or older, and the sample was census-balanced by age and gender. TEAM LEWIS collected data through an online survey fielded from September 25 through September 30, 2024. The survey respondents were independently sourced from Cint, a global market research panel provider that is committed to data integrity.

About Five9

The Five9 Intelligent CX Platform, powered by Five9 Genius AI, provides a comprehensive suite of solutions to power AI-elevated customer experiences that deliver better business outcomes and Bring Joy to CX™. Our unified cloud-native offering enables hyper-personalized customer experiences and more empowered employees, making every customer interaction more connected, effortless, and personal. Trusted by 2,500+ customers and 1,400+ partners globally, Five9 brings together the power of AI, our platform, and our people to drive AI-elevated CX.

For more information, visit www.five9.com.

Engage with us @Five9, LinkedIn, Facebook, Blog